When I read the comments made to anyone’s website articles, I can only conclude that the commenters believe the quoted pundit to be either completely ignorant or really evil. I know from personal experience that I substitute financial Ouija board wisdom for useful analysis.
That’s why I stopped reading comments on free mass market websites altogether. If I want to learn about how dumb and out of touch I am I can just ring up my kids. That’s too bad, because the 95% of the comments calling me an idiot swamp the 5% of commenters with legitimate questions or constructive disagreements.
Let’s break down what a TV (or substitute your favorite media) talking head is really doing. First, I truly believe that most of them are just working stiffs trying to further their careers by donating their analysis for free on a news program. They think that they need to be right in their calls. Well, at least mostly right. If they blow it all the time then they will not be asked back again.
Don’t gloss over that word “free.” They are not paid for their appearances and at most get a free limo ride from their office to the studio. The real value is more intangible – exposure. The more times you see a so-called expert the more you come to trust him/her. They hope that translates into book sales, newsletter subscriptions and new clients for their firms.
Let’s say Talking Head X says the stock market is going to go up and banks will lead the way. You make a mental note and go about your business.
Within a week, the stock market goes down and the news of the day sends bank stocks reeling. Was the pundit a moron? Or did they want you to buy so they could sell into the bump?
Either way, you wonder how they still get the big bucks, let alone still have a job after such a boneheaded call.
But what was the pundit’s responsibility to you? He/she was just interviewed for their opinion. You did not pay for it. And even more important, you were not privy to when he/she put out an alert to clients saying that things changed and they should not buy bank stocks, or at least get out immediately.
You judged Talking Head X on one moment in time that was, admittedly, incorrect, but not necessarily a money loser. Remember, none of us are in this business to be correct. We are here to make money. Similar to baseball, if you get one third of your calls right and use proper money management (cut losers and ride winners) then you get very rich.
Here is my favorite quote in the comments sections – “If this analysis had any value he/she would be trading it and not talking about it.” Therefore, this pundit is a huckster.
Do you think the same thing when you see an advertisement for an engineering training course or a set of ratchet wrenches? After all, if you can train people to engineer something then you should already be applying it to build a driverless car that runs on bitcoin.
Just because you learned to swing a hammer does not make you a master carpenter. Therefore, just because you learn to read a chart or a balance sheet does not make you Warren Buffett (and I mean that to emphasize the “oracle” part of his nickname).
You can learn plenty from TV talking heads but don’t take what they say as fiduciary trading advice tailored to your unique situation. If you do, it is you, not the pundit, who is the fool.